Quiz – Baffling Batters (solved)

Here’s a seemingly random assortment of batters. Yet, these are the only players with a post-war season (since 1946) achieving a particular batting feat. What is it?

Hint: the fact that these players were all outfielders is not germane to the answer.

Congratulations to Richard Chester and Gary Bateman! They teamed up to identify that these are the only players to qualify for the league batting title in their rookies seasons, while batting .300 with 150 or fewer hits and 10 or more home runs.

More on precocious batters after the jump.

Of these eight players, none would bat .300 for their careers, though Rico Carty came very close at .299. There have been 55 players to bat .300 in a qualifying rookie season since 1946, including 45 who are now retired. Of those retired players, only the following eight would bat .300 for their careers.

Rk Player BA From To Age G PA R H 2B 3B HR RBI BB SO OBP SLG OPS Tm
1 Nomar Garciaparra .313 1996 2009 22-35 1434 6116 927 1747 370 52 229 936 403 554 .361 .521 .882 BOS-TOT-CHC-LAD-OAK
2 Dale Mitchell .312 1946 1956 24-34 1127 4358 555 1244 169 61 41 403 346 119 .368 .416 .784 CLE-TOT
3 Mike Piazza .308 1992 2007 23-38 1912 7745 1048 2127 344 8 427 1335 759 1113 .377 .545 .922 LAD-TOT-NYM-SDP-OAK
4 Richie Ashburn .308 1948 1962 21-35 2189 9736 1322 2574 317 109 29 586 1198 571 .396 .382 .778 PHI-CHC-NYM
5 Bill Madlock .305 1973 1987 22-36 1806 7372 920 2008 348 34 163 860 605 510 .365 .442 .807 TEX-CHC-SFG-TOT-PIT-LAD
6 Tony Oliva .304 1962 1976 23-37 1676 6880 870 1917 329 48 220 947 448 645 .353 .476 .830 MIN
7 Harvey Kuenn .303 1952 1966 21-35 1833 7617 951 2092 356 56 87 671 594 404 .357 .408 .765 DET-CLE-SFG-TOT
8 Billy Goodman .300 1947 1962 21-36 1623 6443 807 1691 299 44 19 591 669 329 .376 .378 .754 BOS-TOT-CHW-HOU
Provided by Baseball-Reference.com: View Play Index Tool Used
Generated 9/3/2013.

The group above stands a good chance of being augmented with several of the following active players who batted .300 in a qualifying rookie season and are still batting .300 for their careers.

Rk Player BA From To Age G PA R H 2B 3B HR RBI BB SO OBP SLG OPS Tm
1 Albert Pujols .321 2001 2013 21-33 1958 8546 1425 2347 524 15 492 1498 1067 835 .410 .599 1.008 STL-LAA
2 Ichiro Suzuki .320 2001 2013 27-39 2040 9209 1254 2729 322 83 111 692 540 862 .362 .416 .778 SEA-TOT-NYY
3 Mike Trout .319 2011 2013 19-21 311 1378 244 379 68 17 58 181 159 276 .402 .551 .953 LAA
4 Todd Helton .317 1997 2013 23-39 2226 9366 1389 2500 584 37 365 1393 1329 1156 .415 .540 .955 COL
5 Derek Jeter .313 1995 2013 21-39 2597 11946 1873 3313 525 65 256 1260 1043 1751 .381 .447 .828 NYY
6 Dustin Pedroia .302 2006 2013 22-29 994 4448 637 1189 281 13 98 485 417 396 .370 .455 .825 BOS
Provided by Baseball-Reference.com: View Play Index Tool Used
Generated 9/3/2013.

No qualifying rookie batters in 2013 are currently threatening .300. J.B. Schuck of the Angels looks to have the best chance – he’s not currently qualified but is batting .297 and needs 104 PA in the Angels’ final 26 games to have a qualifying season. Possible, but Schuck would need to play pretty much every day.

If Schuck does finish at .300 and qualifies for the batting title, the Angels will have had two such rookies in consecutive seasons, something only these post-war teams can boast of.

Rk Player Year BA Age Tm G PA R H 2B 3B HR RBI BB SO OBP SLG OPS
10 Chris Singleton (RoY-6th) 1999 .300 26 CHW 133 530 72 149 31 6 17 72 22 45 .328 .490 .818
12 Mike Caruso (RoY-3rd) 1998 .306 21 CHW 133 555 81 160 17 6 5 55 14 38 .331 .390 .721
17 Raul Mondesi (RoY-1st) 1994 .306 23 LAD 112 454 63 133 27 8 16 56 16 78 .333 .516 .849
18 Mike Piazza (RoY-1st) 1993 .318 24 LAD 149 602 81 174 24 2 35 112 46 86 .370 .561 .932
51 Billy Goodman (RoY-4th) 1948 .310 22 BOS 127 527 65 138 27 2 1 66 74 44 .414 .387 .801
52 Sam Mele 1947 .302 25 BOS 123 498 71 137 14 8 12 73 37 35 .356 .448 .805
Provided by Baseball-Reference.com: View Play Index Tool Used
Generated 9/3/2013.

Additionally, these has been just one team since 1946 with two such rookies in the same season.

Rk Player Year BA Age Tm G PA AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI BB SO OBP SLG OPS
27 Fred Lynn (RoY-1st) 1975 .331 23 BOS 145 605 528 103 175 47 7 21 105 62 90 .401 .566 .967
28 Jim Rice (RoY-2nd) 1975 .309 22 BOS 144 613 564 92 174 29 4 22 102 36 122 .350 .491 .841
Provided by Baseball-Reference.com: View Play Index Tool Used
Generated 9/3/2013.
0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

9 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Chris C
Chris C
10 years ago

Does it have to do with their rookie seasons? They all had a very good first year.

Richard Chester
Richard Chester
10 years ago

It looks to me like the players are listed in descending order of PA in their first qualifying season and they all hit .300 or more.

Richard Chester
Richard Chester
10 years ago

Make that descending order of BA.

Voomo Zanzibar
Voomo Zanzibar
10 years ago

They are also all outfielders.

Richard Chester
Richard Chester
10 years ago

From 1946 to date they are the only players with a .300+ BA, fewer than 500 AB, HR greater than 10 in their rookie year and qualified for the batting title.

Gary Bateman
Gary Bateman
10 years ago

How about hits less than or equal to 150?