COG 1920 Results: Stan’s Up and Gets Counted

For the second round in a row, one candidate dominated the voting by an overwhelming margin. This time it was Stan Musial, appearing on a COG-record 94% of the ballots cast. Musial becomes the 63rd inductee in the High Heat Stats Circle of Greats. More on Stan and the voting, after the jump.

Over the 44-season period from 1922 through 1965, here are the top players in the majors in terms of total Wins Above Replacement (“WAR”, baseball-reference version):
1. Stan Musial 128.1
2. Ted Williams 123.1
3. Willie Mays 120.3
4. Babe Ruth 118.1
5. Lou Gehrig 112.4

Most Total Bases, Major League History:
1. Hank Aaron 6,856
2. Stan Musial 6,134
3. Willie Mays 6,066
4. Barry Bonds 5,976
5. Ty Cobb 5,854

Most WAR by a Hitter Who Played for Only One Franchise in His Career, MLB History:
1. Stan Musial 128.1
2. Ted Williams 123.1
3. Lou Gehrig 112.4
4. Mickey Mantle 109.7
5. Mel Ott 107.8
6. Mike Schmidt 106.5
7. Carl Yastremski 96.1
8. Cal Ripken 95.5
9. Roberto Clemente 94.4
10. Al Kaline 92.5

Musial is number #5 in career WAR in NL history, behind Bonds, Aaron, Mays and Honus Wagner, but when he retired at the close of the 1963 season, Stan was #2, slightly behind Wagner.

Most WAR in the National League, 1876-1963:
1. Honus Wagner 131.0
2. Stan Musial 128.1
3. Rogers Hornsby 126.3
4. Mel Ott 107.8
5. Willie Mays 98.0

Most Games Batting Third in the Order, 1914-2014
1. Stan Musial 2,225
2. Ken Griffey, Jr. 2,017
3. Carl Yastrzemski 1,980
4. Billy Williams 1,958
5. Willie Mays 1,939

And lastly, a link: Joe Posnanski on Musial, which may at least partly explain why Stan received a record share of support this round.

***************************************

Notes on the 1920 round:

–Besides Musial, the rest of the story this round is pretty straightforward. All 14 holdovers received between 7 and 14 votes, all appearing on more than 10% but less than 21% of the ballots. So all 14 remain just as they were in terms of future eligibility. Newcomers to the ballot Early Wynn, Bob Lemon and Vern Stephens received bits of support from voters but none were ever really in contention to remain on the ballot.

–Ralph Kiner and Hoyt Wilhelm, who don’t have much in common in terms of their baseball profiles (similarity score of zero, one might say), were born three months apart and in their three rounds since joining the COG ballot have received votes of 15, 9 and 8 (Wilhelm) and 16, 8 and 9 (Kiner).

***************************************
The full spreadsheet showing this round’s vote tally is here: COG 1920 Vote Tally.

The vote summary for recent Circle of Greats voting rounds is here: COG Vote Summary 2 .  An archive with details of the 1968 through 1939 rounds is here: COG 1968-1939 Vote Summary .  In both cases, raw vote totals for each past round appear on Sheet 1 and the percentage totals for each past round appear on Sheet 2.

***************************************
A spreadsheet listing the full membership to date of the Circle of Greats, along with some of their stats, is here: Circle of Greats Membership . You can also find that same link any time by clicking on “Circle of Greats” at the top of the High Heats Stats home page.

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

3 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Dr. Doom
Dr. Doom
9 years ago

Since I was posting this stuff over in the other thread, I think it’d be nice to see the final updates on the lopsidedness of Musial’s victory: As birtelcom mentioned, Musial’s 94.12% is the most of any player in the COG. Also, Musial’s margin of victory was 50 votes over Willie McCovey. That’s far-and-away the most ever. Warren Spahn (55-15 over McCovey), Mike Schmidt (+42 over John Smoltz) and Randy Johnson (+45 over Curt Schilling) were even over 40. Finally, Musial finished the round with 64 votes. Greg Maddux (68 in 1966) and Randy Johnson (66 in 1963) are the… Read more »

Artie Z.
Artie Z.
9 years ago
Reply to  Dr. Doom

Seeing as how Musial set records against this candidate pool, and that Jackie Robinson will be facing basically the same candidate pool minus whoever gets elected (Ford or McCovey or Lofton or whoever) – I think the only question is if Jackie will break Stan the Man’s “records” in the next round.

Dr. Doom
Dr. Doom
9 years ago

One more comment. I know a couple people were interested in the COG all-time vote leader update I gave last round. Here’s another (all players with 100+ votes; *=currently on the ballot): John Smoltz – 658 *Craig Biggio – 637 *Ryne Sandberg – 528 Edgar Martinez – 507 Lou Whitaker – 493 *Kenny Lofton – 489 *Roberto Alomar – 442 *Eddie Murray – 423 Bobby Grich – 376 Sandy Koufax – 375 Tony Gwynn – 346 *Willie McCovey – 306 Juan Marichal – 268 Tom Glavine – 262 Alan Trammell – 239 Mike Mussina – 233 Curt Schilling – 224… Read more »