All I want for Christmas is …

In the spirit of the season, here’s a rundown of some of the more notable transactions occurring on Christmas Eve and Christmas Day.

Possibly the most important Christmas signing occurred in 1964 when the woeful Kansas City A’s began putting together the pieces of a future dynasty, acquiring an undrafted 18 year-old pitcher with the unlikely name of Rollie Fingers. That 1964 season also saw the A’s debuts of Dave Duncan and Blue Moon Odom, two other teenagers who would figure prominently in the first of Oakland’s three 1970s championship seasons.

The A’s made another big Christmas signing in 1992, re-upping free agent slugger Mark McGwire, a fixture on Oakland’s 1988-90 pennant winning teams. Alas, McGwire missed considerable playing time over his next five seasons, but when he was in the lineup Big Mac was a force, slashing .291/.433/.665 over that period and launching homers at a rate of one every 11.8 PA, including a league-leading 52 in 1996, and 34 the next season before a deadline deal trade to the Cardinals.

The defending world champion Braves tried to solidify their top standing when they traded for outfielder Sherry Magee in 1914. Magee’s 46.5 WAR over the preceding decade ranked second in the NL, (far) behind only the incomparable Honus Wagner. Though Magee was only 30 and coming off a season leading the senior circuit in hits, slugging and RBI, his decline phase came on rapidly, slashing just .262/.331/.358 in three seasons with the Braves, quite a drop from his .299/.371/.447 line for the Phillies.

The Red Sox were another defending world champion looking to secure its future prospects when they resigned free agent catcher Jason Varitek in 2004. Coming off a career best season at age 32, Varitek almost matched it the next year before his decline phase set in. Still, he would catch 90+ games each year until his age 37 season, a run that included a second world championship campaign in 2007.

Yet another defending world champion reeled in a big name star (albeit with a little tarnish on him after a sub-par season the year before) when the Yankees acquired left-hander David Wells in 1996. Wells would play four seasons in New York, two of them pennant campaigns, including a World Series title in 1998. New York’s dominance and Yankee Stadium’s decided home field advantage for lefties allowed Wells to parlay an okay 114 ERA+ into a gaudy 68-28 record (.708) for the Bombers.

The Browns departed from form and also went shopping for a name pitcher in his mid-thirties when the usually cash-strapped franchise found $20,000 to purchase Johnny Allen from the Indians in 1940. Unlike Wells, though, Allen was basically done and St. Louis waived him midway through the 1941 season after the one-time ace posted a 2-5 record with a 6.58 ERA. Allen got picked up by the Dodgers and finished his career with limited innings as an NL swingman.

Going the less expensive route to upgrade their talent were the Reds, a season removed from their 1919 world championship when they acquired Bubbles Hargrave in 1920 from the St. Paul Saints of the American Association. Hargrave had been out of the majors for five years but the astute Reds noted he was coming off two .300 seasons as the Saints’ everyday catcher. Hargrave was never an everyday player in Cincinnati but contributed 300+ PA for seven straight seasons (1922-28), including a league batting title with a .353 average in 1926, and a .314/.377/.461 slash in more than 2500 PA for the Reds.

The Dodgers were coming off an NLCS appearance when they resigned free agent third baseman Juan Uribe in 2013. The stocky third sacker responded by turning in pretty much a carbon copy of his career best season of the year before as LA repeated its NL West title. Uribe became the tenth third baseman to record 8 WAR aged 34-35 and just the fourth to do so averaging better than 0.9 WAR per 100 PA.

The Brewers went shopping in 2006 and bagged Cardinals’ ace Jeff Suppan, coming off three stellar seasons in St. Louis, two of them pennant campaigns, including a world championship that season. Suppan could manage only 84 ERA+ in 3+ seasons in Milwaukee, though the 2008 team did make a post-season appearance (the first for the Brewers in 26 years) with Suppan playing the role of veteran mentor to four twenty-something starters.

The Rangers had traded during the 1995 season to reacquire Bobby Witt, then resigned him as a free agent that Christmas. In his first stint with Texas, Witt was a hard thrower who was also very wild, leading the AL three times in walks and twice in wild pitches. In his return engagement, Witt wasn’t quite the flame thrower he had been in his younger days, but had a lot better control, albeit still north of four BB/9 as the Rangers took the AL West crown in 1996 to claim the franchise’s first post-season appearance in its 36th season.

I’ll close with Happy Townsend, known to HHS readers as the pitcher with a .293 career W-L%, worst by over 30 points among all pitchers with 100+ decisions since 1901. Townsend had already compiled those 100 decisions with a sub-.300 career W-L% when the Senators finally gave up on the youngster, still only 26 as the 1905 season ended. Thus, it is probably a bit surprising to learn that Townsend was traded twice that off-season, both times in a straight up swap for a three time 19-game winner. First to jump at Townsend was Detroit, offering up former Dodger ace Frank Kitson, followed on Christmas Eve 1905 by the Naps who parted with erstwhile Phillie ace Red Donahue (who actually had four 19 win seasons, including three with 20+ victories). To be fair, Kitson and Donahue were pretty much done, each playing his final season as a regular the next year (as did Townsend, in limited innings). Donahue at least went out in style, as he remains the only AL pitcher to close out his career with a 200 IP season of 12+ wins and ERA under 3.00 (the only other AL pitcher to wind up his career with a 200 IP season with ERA under 3.00 was Donahue contemporary George Winter who managed only a 5-19 record for the Red Sox and Tigers in 1908).

Merry Christmas everyone!

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

11 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Voomo Zanzibar
7 years ago

Townsend contributed to an historically bad team in 1904, with the 38-113 Senators. Here are the worst team WAA (Wins Above Average) through 1945: -33.0 … PHA 1915 -29.8 … SLB 1910 -29.7 … BSN 1911 -29.4 … WSH 1904 -28.4 … PHI 1945 -26.7 … PHI 1928 -25.5 … PHA 1916 -25.4 … SLB 1939 -24.8 … PHA 1920 -24.8 … PHA 1936 -24.1 … PHI 1938 -24.0 … PHI 1939 -23.7 … PHA 1943 -22.9 … NYY 1908 -22.8 … WSH 1909 -22.4 … PHI 1921 -22.4 … BSN 1924 -22.3 … BRO 1905 Yes, the city of… Read more »

Hartvig
Hartvig
7 years ago
Reply to  Voomo Zanzibar

At least they had a little pity on the good people of Philadelphia by never having both franchises on the list in the same year.

Paul E
Paul E
7 years ago

I have lived in PHI my entire life. The 1970-1972 teams were flat-out awful. A bunch of young talent that eventually played well here and elsewhere…..not quite as bad as recent Tigers and Astros teams, though

Mike L
Mike L
7 years ago
Reply to  Paul E

Fun fact. The 1970-1972 Phillies had Woody Fryman. The 1996 Tigers (53-109, -30 WAA) had Travis Fryman

Paul E
Paul E
7 years ago
Reply to  Mike L

Mike L,
I was thinking more along the lines of the 2003 Tigers (43-119) and 2013 Astros (111 losses). Cornejo, Maroth, and Bonderman lost 57 between them while sporting ERA+’s in the 70’s

Mike L
Mike L
7 years ago
Reply to  Paul E

I figured that. On a lark, I checked the negative WAA for those teams. The 2003 Tigers were -29.9, and the 2013 Astros were -24.7. The 1996 Tigers were actually the cream of the crop. The 1996 Tigers pitching staff was remarkable–ERA of 6.38, WHIP of 1.733, ERA+ of 80.

Paul E
Paul E
7 years ago
Reply to  Mike L

That’s pretty ugly. And, almost hard to believe they were that bad on the mound. Kind of like the 1930 Phillies – just bad pitching ‘talent’ in the midst of the greatest hitter’s eras ever.

Voomo Zanzibar
7 years ago
Reply to  Paul E

Here’s how bad they were. 16 pitchers started games for the 1996 Tigers.
Those 16 collectively had a career Pitching WAR of 50.6

4.8 … Felipe Lira
13.2 . Omar Olivares
-4.4 .. Brian Williams
0.4 … Greg Gohr
13.0 . Justin Thompson (7.7 WAR in 1997)
0.8 … A.J. Sager
-0.5 .. Todd Van Poppel
-0.9 .. C.J. Nitkowski
-2.4 .. Scott Aldred
-1.6 .. Clint Sodowsky
-0.9 .. Greg Keagle
6.0 … José Lima
4.7 … Trever Miller
-1.2 .. Tom Urbani
12.3 . Brian Moehler
7.3 … John Farrell

Mike L
Mike L
7 years ago
Reply to  Voomo Zanzibar

Jose Lima had a remarkable career. 13 seasons, 6.0 cumulative bWAR–but 8.4 in 1998 and 1999. In 1999 he finished 4th in NL Cy Young voting. The following year his performance was spectacularly bad. 6.65 ERA, 48 HR allowed in 196 IP. Career ERA+ of 85. It’s amazing he kept getting opportunities to pitch.

mosc
mosc
7 years ago
Reply to  Voomo Zanzibar

Todd Van Poppel, another name to bring up when people are SURE they’re team’s latest pitching prospect is going to be a star.