Author Archives: John Autin

Walk rates for hitters in uncertain pursuit of 3,000 hits

At Andy’s suggestion (see comment #17 here), I did a quick-and-dirty study of late-career walk rates for players who finished with around 3,000 hits.

The hypothesis to be tested is that players approaching both 3,000 hits and the end of their career tend to walk less often than they did before.

Included in the study were 30 players who wound up with 2,800 to 3,200 hits. I excluded those whose careers ended before “3,000 hits” became an iconic target (i.e., Sam Crawford and Willie Keeler).

I calculated their walk rates (BB per 700 PAs) for 4 periods:

  • Career minus their last 3 seasons;
  • Last 3 seasons;
  • Last 2 seasons; and
  • Last season.

Any period with less than 200 PAs is presented as “n/a” in the table. (Apologies for the table formatting, which I can’t seem to control.)

Walk Rates for Players Who Finished with 2,800 – 3,200 Hits

Hits

BB per 700 PAs

Player

Career
-3 yrs

Last
3 yrs

Last
2 yrs

Last
1 yr

3184

64

36

40

35

Cal Ripken

3154

69

51

41

45

George Brett

3152

70

103

n/a

n/a

Paul Waner

3142

54

62

59

60

Robin Yount

3141

54

48

53

n/a

Tony Gwynn

3110

70

60

69

n/a

Dave Winfield

3088

63

61

57

53

Derek Jeter

3060

69

39

38

29

Craig Biggio

3055

115

118

112

n/a

Rickey Henderson

3053

66

79

81

86

Rod Carew

3023

49

38

37

37

Lou Brock

3020

77

86

84

71

Rafael Palmeiro

3010

94

75

72

80

Wade Boggs

3007

78

66

67

72

Al Kaline

3000

42

46

40

49

Roberto Clemente

2987

48

56

46

53

Sam Rice

2943

83

108

123

n/a

Frank Robinson

2935

139

175

178

194

Barry Bonds

2930

77

80

81

n/a

Rogers Hornsby

2927

45

37

38

n/a

Al Simmons

2884

46

42

38

46

Zack Wheat

2880

49

63

68

n/a

Frankie Frisch

2876

106

90

n/a

n/a

Mel Ott

2873

135

146

154

n/a

Babe Ruth

2866

66

76

74

n/a

Harold Baines

2848

51

48

30

n/a

Brooks Robinson

2844

35

31

33

n/a

Ivan Rodriguez

2841

61

51

53

n/a

Omar Vizquel

2839

76

117

121

n/a

Charlie Gehringer

2812

37

35

34

34

George Sisler

Over all, I do not see a consistent pattern that would confirm the hypothesis. But the following players did have a marked decline in walk rate in their later years:

Compared to the 3 preceding years, Cal Ripken‘s walk rate fell by 54% in 1999, the year when he would have reached 3,000 hits if not for a couple of DL stints. (He got hit #2,991 in game #149, but played no more that year.) Ripken averaged 57 BB/700 PAs for the preceding 3 years, but that rate fell to 26 in 1999 (13 walks in 354 PAs). If he was pressing, though, it sure didn’t affect his hitting — his .340 BA, .584 SLG and .952 OPS were all career highs, and his SO rate was a couple of % points below his career rate.

Ripken got hit #3,000 in the 10th game of 2000. In the previous 9 games, he drew a normal 4 walks in 39 PAs.

George Brett‘s walk rate fell 46% from the prior 3-year average in 1992, the year in which he reached 3,000 hits on Sept. 30 with a 4-hit game. Brett averaged 71 BB/700 for the prior 3 years, but just 38 that year. And his BB rate was even lower in the run-up to that game — 7 walks in 229 PAs from August 1 to Sept. 30, and none at all in the 20 games immediately before the big one.

After a sterling ’92 capped by a go-ahead hit in WS game 7, Dave Winfield began 1993 needing 134 hits for 3,000, having averaged 72 BB/700 PAs for the previous 3 years. That rate fell to 53 in 1993, but coincided with a general decline in performance. There was no particular variance in his walk rate in the 20 to 50 games leading up to hit #3,000.

Craig Biggio began 2007 needing 70 hits for 3,000, having averaged just 42 BB/700 PAs for the prior 3 years (already well below his previous career average of 71). In 2007, his final year, Biggio’s walk rate dropped further, to 29 BB/700 PA. In the 30 games culminating in hit #3,000 (and a baserunning boo-boo), Biggio was hacking to the tune of 3 walks and 26 Ks in 118 PAs.

Well, I was going to write up a few more, but I ran out of time….

100 wins and still with his original team

Thanks to offseason transactions, Justin Verlander is now the only active 100-game winner who is still with his original team. Verlander is signed with Detroit for another three years.

As you see in the table below, there were two such pitchers at the end of 2011, both toiling in the Windy City:

Rk Player Franch. W ▾ L ERA ERA+ WAR From To Age G GS CG SHO IP BB SO HR Tm
1 Mark Buehrle 1 161 119 3.83 120 46.6 2000 2011 21-32 390 365 27 8 2476.2 564 1396 274 CHW
2 Carlos Zambrano 1 125 81 3.60 122 31.8 2001 2011 20-30 319 282 9 4 1826.2 823 1542 152 CHC
3 Justin Verlander 1 107 57 3.54 124 27.2 2005 2011 22-28 199 199 14 5 1315.1 410 1215 118 DET
4 Ervin Santana 1 87 67 4.22 101 15.8 2005 2011 22-28 206 203 13 6 1297.2 414 1034 164 LAA
5 Brandon Webb 1 87 62 3.27 142 29.2 2003 2009 24-30 199 198 15 8 1319.2 435 1065 92 ARI
6 Felix Hernandez 1 85 67 3.24 129 29.1 2005 2011 19-25 205 205 18 4 1388.1 424 1264 116 SEA
7 Jered Weaver 1 82 47 3.31 128 26.8 2006 2011 23-28 177 177 8 4 1131.2 308 977 121 LAA
Provided by Baseball-Reference.com: View Play Index Tool Used
Generated 2/3/2012.

But those 2011 leaders are now both with Miami: Mark Buehrle went free agent after 161 wins in the pale hose (#6 on the franchise list, 2 shy of Wilbur Wood), while Carlos Zambrano was mercy-traded to the Marlins after wearing out his welcome both on and off the Wrigley playing field. Big Z is #11 on the Cubs’ career list with 125 wins, 3 short of Pete Alexander.

Only three other active one-team pitchers have 80+ wins: Ervin Santana (87) and Jered Weaver (82) of the Angels, and Seattle’s Felix Hernandez (85), who is the active SP leader in WAR for his original team (29.1 to Verlander’s 27.2). All three are under contract for at least the next two years, though there is much trade speculation about King Felix.

Buehrle’s departure from the South Side means that Ron Guidry remains the one-franchise leader in the free-agent era with 170 wins:

Rk Player Franch. W ▾ L ERA ERA+ WAR From To Age G GS CG SHO SV IP BB SO HR Tm
1 Ron Guidry 1 170 91 3.29 119 44.4 1975 1988 24-37 368 323 95 26 4 2392.0 633 1778 226 NYY
2 Mark Buehrle 1 161 119 3.83 120 46.6 2000 2011 21-32 390 365 27 8 0 2476.2 564 1396 274 CHW
3 Brad Radke 1 148 139 4.22 113 41.4 1995 2006 22-33 378 377 37 10 0 2451.0 445 1467 326 MIN
4 Dennis Leonard 1 144 102 3.68 107 24.2 1975 1986 24-35 307 298 103 23 1 2165.0 610 1315 202 KCR
5 Jim Palmer 1 139 83 2.98 124 35.8 1975 1984 29-38 290 278 113 27 2 2081.1 622 1035 170 BAL
6 Scott McGregor 1 138 108 3.99 99 17.5 1976 1988 22-34 356 309 83 23 5 2140.2 518 904 235 BAL
7 Steve Rogers 1 133 125 3.13 117 40.3 1975 1985 25-35 344 338 111 33 2 2450.0 747 1403 127 MON
8 Carlos Zambrano 1 125 81 3.60 122 31.8 2001 2011 20-30 319 282 9 4 0 1826.2 823 1542 152 CHC
9 Bob Stanley 1 115 97 3.64 119 21.5 1977 1989 22-34 637 85 21 7 132 1707.0 471 693 113 BOS
10 Paul Splittorff 1 113 91 3.91 102 11.5 1975 1984 28-37 296 262 50 8 1 1697.2 520 627 134 KCR
11 Justin Verlander 1 107 57 3.54 124 27.2 2005 2011 22-28 199 199 14 5 0 1315.1 410 1215 118 DET
12 Mario Soto 1 100 92 3.47 108 26.9 1977 1988 20-31 297 224 72 13 4 1730.1 657 1449 172 CIN
Provided by Baseball-Reference.com: View Play Index Tool Used
Generated 2/3/2012.

From 1920 through 1974 — comprising 958 team-seasons — there were 30 pitchers with at least 200 wins, of which 15 won 200+ on behalf of one team (whether or not they also pitched elsewhere). But since the dawn of free agency in 1975 (comprising 1,024 team-seasons), only 3 out of 23 pitchers with 200 wins did so for one team: teammates Tom Glavine (244) and John Smoltz (210) with Atlanta, and Andy Pettitte (203) with the Yankees. Three more came close: Jack Morris won 198 with Detroit, Greg Maddux 194 with Atlanta and Roger Clemens 192 with Boston.

Sidebar: Verlander and Weaver have been linked ever since they were drafted in 2004:

  • Verlander went #2 over all that year, while Weaver (the collegiate player of the year) slipped to #12 due to “signability concerns” (Latin name: Borasthesia).
  • Both were MLB fixtures within 2 years; Verlander broke camp with the 2006 Tigers and wound up as Rookie of the Year, while Weaver was called up in late May and placed 5th on that ballot.
  • Each has at least 11 wins every year since 2006; they rank #1 and #4 in AL wins in that span.
  • Verlander led the majors in strikeouts last year, Weaver the year before.
  • Verlander edged Weaver for the AL ERA crown last year, 2.40 to 2.41.
  • Verlander also holds a slim edge in their 5 career face-offs, with a 3-2 record and 3.89 ERA, compared to 2-3, 4.50 for Weaver.
  • Their career bWAR values are virtually the same — 27.2 for Verlander, 26.8 for Weaver.

 

Young position stars of 2010-11

In case you’ve forgotten, here are the top bWAR seasons over the past 2 years by players who will be 26 or under in 2012.

All seasons of at least 3.9 WAR are listed. No SS or 2B reached that level, so in order to round out a lineup (see the top 8 in the table), I’ve included the top figure at each position. (Dustin Ackley’s 2.5 WAR in 90 games does project to 4.5 per 162G.) Lastly, I included Brett Lawrie’s 2011 on the grounds of  his tremendous rate of 10.5 WAR per 162 games. Continue reading