Dalton joined me for lunch a few weeks ago in the land of lobster and oversized novelty boots. We got to talking about Barry Bonds, offensive environments, and asterisks. Both of us are irked by fans willing to completely ignore individual accomplishments based on single factors like PEDs or Coors Field.
Rather than removing these numbers from history with asterisks, official or personal, the thinking fan, we agreed, has an obligation to adjust certain individual accomplishments for context. Roger Maris had eight more games in which to hit his 61 homers than Babe Ruth got to hit his 60. Mark McGwire took 3,500 CCs more androstenedione than Maris in hitting his 70. Barry Bonds got to play six more games in Coors Field than McGwire when he hit his 70 (but also played 78 more in San Francisco). While some of these factors are more difficult to control for, we should be able to determine who hit the most home runs relative to his peers.


