Circle of Greats 1951 Ballot Results: Going Dutch

Bert Blyleven is the 21st inductee into the High Heat Stats Circle of Greats and, as a native of the Netherlands, our first inductee born in a nation with no major league team.

While it took 14 long years of voting with Blyleven on the ballot for the Baseball Writers Association of America to induct Bert into the Hall of Fame, COG voters have now inducted him at the first opportunity.  You picked Bert in preference to ten guys that the BBWAA elected while making Blyleven wait (Gwynn, Sandberg, Murray, Dawson, Winfield, Puckett, Rice, Sutter, Eckersley and Gossage).   More on Byleven and the 1951 round of voting is after the jump.

Top Pitching WAR in an Age 22 Season, over the past 100 seasons (1913-2012):
1. Bert Blyleven (1973) 9.9 WAR
2. Hubert “Dutch” Leonard (1914) 9.3
3. Larry Dierker (1969) 8.6
4. Bill James (1914) 8.2
T5. Bob Feller (1941) and Sam McDowell (1965) 8.1

Top Pitching WAR in an Age 38 Season, over the past 100 seasons (1913-2012):
1. Randy Johnson (2002) 10.9 WAR
2. Phil Niekro (1977) 8.9
3. Emil “Dutch” Leonard (1947) 6.6
4. Bert Blyleven (1989) 6.0
5. Babe Adams (1920) 5.8

Since 1901, only Roger Clemens, Randy Johnson, Nolan Ryan and Steve Carlton have struck out more batters than Bert Blyleven.

Seven hitters faced Bert Blyleven more than 100 times over their careers.  Three of those seven guys were Hall of Famers.  The records of those three guys when they faced Blyleven:

Reggie Jackson (140 PAs) .214 BA/.264 OBP/.397 SLG/.661 OPS
George Brett (128 PAs) .231 BA/.281 OBP/.342 SLG/.623 OPS
Robin Yount (114 PAs) .182 BA/.211 OBP/.300 SLG/.511 OPS

*******************

This round’s 1951 birth-year newcomers garnered enough interest, even beyond Blyleven, that the holdover group has now been re-stocked with three new members: Dave Winfield, Goose Gossage and Dwight Evans.  And there was enough continuing support for the existing group of nine holdovers that none of them were knocked out either.

But the voting, other than for Blyleven, was so widely spread around that no one on the bubble reached the 25% support level required to get off the bubble next round (Ryne Sandberg and Dave Winfield came close but fell just short).  So next round will see six, count ’em six, holdovers at risk of losing their spots on the ballot.  On the bright side for those guys, after the 1950 vote is complete we’ll do our every-ten-birth-years redemption round.

Tony Gwynn, who always gets solid support from the COG voters, came into this round averaging 22 votes per round, and this round he received: 22 votes.

Voting participation generally was up this round, to a level (65 ballots submitted) we haven’t seen the past five rounds.

As usual, you can check out the complete voting record for this past round at Google Docs. The link is here: 1951 COG Vote Tally

If you would like to review the history of the COG voting, a spreadsheet summary of the voting is here: COG Vote Summary , with a summary of the raw vote totals on Sheet 1 and a summary of the percentage totals on Sheet 2.

The Circle of Greats membership thus far:
Jeff Bagwell
Bert Blyleven
Wade Boggs
Barry Bonds
George Brett
Gary Carter
Roger Clemens
Tom Glavine
Rickey Henderson
Randy Johnson
Barry Larkin
Greg Maddux
Paul Molitor
Mike Mussina
Mike Piazza
Cal Ripken, Jr.
Curt Schilling
Ozzie Smith
Frank Thomas
Larry Walker
Robin Yount

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

16 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Chris C
Chris C
10 years ago

You listed Dawson twice on the players elected by the BBWAA. So only ten guys, not eleven?

Darien
10 years ago

Minor error: you have Brett’s and Yount’s OPS listed as OBP. Otherwise, good stuff!

Fireworks
Fireworks
10 years ago

You meant Randy instead of Walter re: more strikeouts.

Bryan O'Connor
Editor
10 years ago

Bill James. Is there anything he can’t do?

mosc
mosc
10 years ago

“Top Pitching WAR in an Age 38 Season, over the past 100 seasons (1913-2012):
1. Randy Johnson (1973) 10.9 WAR”

Randy Johnson was 38 in 2002. Just saying.

mosc
mosc
10 years ago
Reply to  birtelcom

Something is WRONG on the INTERNETS! It’s a catastrophe! Ha. Thanks.

mosc
mosc
10 years ago
Reply to  mosc

I like the thought of a 1970’s lineup facing Randy Johnson. They saw Ryan plenty during that era so I guess the the fastball wouldn’t be that unique. Would have been fun to see the express vs unit both in their primes, or at least both 38 year old studs. As far as I know, they didn’t face off until opening day 1992: http://www.baseball-reference.com/boxes/SEA/SEA199204060.shtml Hardly a classic. Ryan was already 45 years old. Neither made it through the 6th. Johnson did get to show Ryan his best impression though later that year: http://www.baseball-reference.com/boxes/TEX/TEX199209270.shtml Johnson struck out 18 throwing 160 pitches…… Read more »

mosc
mosc
10 years ago

Blyleven had 9 shutouts in that 1973 year. Has anybody gotten double figures since? When was the last guy with 10+ in a season? I know Guidry matched 9 in his 1978 season, I was just looking at that when deciding to vote for him.

Rocket had 8 in 1988. Ryan had 9 earlier in his career but never matched it. Johnson was never Mr. Shutout bud did manage 6 (so did Cliff Lee). Any other guys?

wlcmlc
wlcmlc
10 years ago

John Tudor had 10 in 1985.
Jim Palmer had 10 in 1975.

mosc
mosc
10 years ago
Reply to  wlcmlc

John Tudor would not have been my guess for most recent pitcher with double digit shutouts in a season. Not in a hundred guesses.

His first 11 games were nothing remarkable by his standards let alone baseball history:
2-7 W-L, ERA 3.73, 1CG 0SHO
10 of his next 23 games he would go the distance without allowing a run including a 31.2 Inning span with 3 of em. Wow.