Quiz – Sluggers (solved)

What career feat distinguishes these sluggers from among all players to play their entire careers since 1901?

Congratulations to David P and Insert Name Here! They teamed up to identify that only these quiz players have had 5 consecutive seasons since 1901 (excluding seasons lost entirely to military service, in the case of Ted Williams) with 25 home runs, 30 doubles and 100 RBI, while playing at the same primary position (at least 50% of games) in each of those seasons.

More on these most consistent sluggers after the jump.

Here are those streaks, led by Lou Gehrig’s 8 seasons, including 6 first basemen, 3 left-fielders and one shortstop.

Rk Yrs From To Age
1 Lou Gehrig 8 1927 1934 24-31 Ind. Seasons
2 Albert Pujols 7 2004 2010 24-30 Ind. Seasons
3 Mark Teixeira 7 2004 2010 24-30 Ind. Seasons
4 Carlos Delgado 6 1998 2003 26-31 Ind. Seasons
5 Jeff Bagwell 6 1996 2001 28-33 Ind. Seasons
6 Albert Belle 6 1993 1998 26-31 Ind. Seasons
7 Ted Williams 6 1941 1949 22-30 Ind. Seasons
8 Ryan Braun 5 2008 2012 24-28 Ind. Seasons
9 Miguel Tejada 5 2000 2004 26-30 Ind. Seasons
10 Todd Helton 5 1999 2003 25-29 Ind. Seasons
Provided by Baseball-Reference.com: View Play Index Tool Used
Generated 4/16/2014.

These players also had 5+ season streaks of 25/30/100, without the requirement of playing at the same primary position throughout.

Rk Yrs From To Age
1 Miguel Cabrera 9 2004 2012 21-29 Ind. Seasons
2 Manny Ramirez 8 1998 2005 26-33 Ind. Seasons
3 Chipper Jones 5 1999 2003 27-31 Ind. Seasons
4 Stan Musial 5 1953 1957 32-36 Ind. Seasons
5 Chuck Klein 5 1929 1933 24-28 Ind. Seasons
Provided by Baseball-Reference.com: View Play Index Tool Used
Generated 4/16/2014.
0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

22 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
mosc
mosc
10 years ago

All time slugging percentage of the above list:
354
3
28
7
55
34
36
14
2
Braun is currently 15th

Clearly a feat accomplished by a slugger. Maybe it would help to compare Tejada and Braun? Braun is the active guy who probably had the feat noted creating the quiz and Tejada is by far the weakest hitter on that list. But a slugging feat that was not accomplished by Ruth or Bonds? I got nothing.

mosc
mosc
10 years ago
Reply to  mosc

Well, looking at doubles over a couple years screens out a couple of big power guys (Ruth, Bonds) but it leaves off guys like Kent and Cano who pounded doubles year in and year out. Tex did manage 160 doubles in 4 years when he was younger but that’s hardly unprecedented.

mosc
mosc
10 years ago
Reply to  mosc

Kent and Cano never managed to line up their 160 doubles in 4 years with 400 runs and 400 RBI’s. Am I close?

Joe
Joe
10 years ago
Reply to  mosc

If it’s doubles related, you’re going to need something to screen out Joe Medwick. From 1935-1938, he had 458 runs, 540 RBI, and an astounding 213 doubles!

David P
David P
10 years ago

How about something like:

Five or more consecutive seasons with

100+ RBIs
25+ Home Runs
30+ Doubles

I “think” they all meet those criteria. Not sure if anyone else does.

mosc
mosc
10 years ago
Reply to  Doug

5 years totaling 500 runs, 500 RBI’s, 190 doubles and 150 HR’s Medwick’s best 5 year stretch is 111 HR. Kent is 4HR and 20 R short, Cano 4 R and 8 HR short (2008-2013 what a beast). Tex has exactly 500 R in his best 5 year stretch so that’s why I think it’s 5 year total. Tejada clubbed 152 HR in his prime doubles years so 150 seems right on that. May have to tweak the doubles line from 175, not sure exactly where the cutoff is needed. Tex had 194 in those years, braun 197, tejada 193,… Read more »

mosc
mosc
10 years ago
Reply to  mosc

Gotta be pretty high doubles cap. Barry has 168 89-93 (and 3 MVPs). Ruth has 183 19-23. Williams only has 184 in consecutive years but 194 if you take his last year before WWII and his 4 years after. So I guess maybe the doubles cutoff is 184? The Machine produced this feat not just multiple times but any 5 year window you look at in the first 11 of his career. Pujol’s dominance just barely misses these marks when looking 09-13 (478R, 182 2B) keeping in mind he only played 99 games in 2013! He not only did it,… Read more »

Richard Chester
Richard Chester
10 years ago

Does it have to do anything with an age bracket, such as 24-28?

John Autin
Editor
10 years ago

This feels like a Purloined Letter deal. But I may be too feverish to think or speak clearly.

Richard Chester
Richard Chester
10 years ago

I’ll try 4 consecutive seasons of 25+ HR, 30+ 2B, 100+ RBI and 100+ R.

mosc
mosc
10 years ago

Tejada only had 98 runs in 2003. He averaged 100+ over those years but didn’t sustain it every year. A lot of the guys have single year slight drops in one category or another.

Richard Chester
Richard Chester
10 years ago
Reply to  mosc

Thinking this out further Doug probably extracted the data from the PI. I don’t believe consecutive season stats can be retrieved from the PI unless he used something like “from a player’s 3rd through 7th seasons”.

Doug
Doug
10 years ago

Not related to Runs.

I extracted the data from P-I, but manually checked whether matching seasons constituted a streak of 5 or more consecutive seasons.

Insert Name Here
Insert Name Here
10 years ago

5 consecutive seasons of 140+ games played and David P’s criteria (100+ RBIs, 25+ HRs, 30+ 2Bs) applies to all of these guys but Teixeira, and probably wouldn’t eliminate the “few more” players Doug mentioned @7.

5 consecutive seasons of David P’s criteria while playing only one position in the field applies to all of these guys but Gehrig (unless you don’t count the one time he played LF in 1930 and the one time he played RF in 1931).

Bah… this is hard. Will continue trying though.

Richard Chester
Richard Chester
10 years ago

You can add Chipper Jones (1999-2003) to the second list.

Dan Mallon
Dan Mallon
10 years ago

Damn! I was so close to figuring this out, but I never considered the position requirement. Musial threw me off, because I knew he did it too.